All 24 Ice Cream Flavors, ranked by 180 players
Players rank Cookies & Cream #1: it wins 74.2% of its matchups (n = 415) and took the title in 37 of 180 brackets. Cookie Dough and Mint Chocolate Chip follow. Disagree? Ice Cream Flavor Tier List is one tap away.
Updated hourly · last refreshed November 15, 2026
Brackets finished180
Head-to-head picks3,484
Entrants ranked24of 24
Cookies & Cream title share20.6%n = 180
Title odds
Share of 180 finished brackets won
- Cookies & Cream20.6% (37 of 180)
- Cookie Dough13.9% (25 of 180)
- Mint Chocolate Chip7.8% (14 of 180)
- Vanilla6.7% (12 of 180)
- Peanut Butter Cup6.7% (12 of 180)
- Brownie Batter4.4% (8 of 180)
Ice Cream Flavors: the community tier list
Built from win rates across 3,484 picks. Tiers use the win rate steadied toward 50% for entrants with few matchups (S from 75%, A 60%, B 50%, C 40%, D 25%). Steadying pulls a small sample toward the middle, so a high raw rate can sit a tier lower and a low one a tier higher than the rate shown, which is the raw one. What does S tier mean?
Stier, win rate 75% or more
- Nobody yet
Atier, win rate 60% or more
- Cookies & Cream74.2%
- Cookie Dough72.2%
Btier, win rate 50% or more
- Mint Chocolate Chip60.1%
- Vanilla59.8%
- Chocolate58.2%
- Brownie Batter58.0%
- Peanut Butter Cup55.8%
- Birthday Cake51.6%
- Strawberry50.5%
- Rocky Road50.5%
Ctier, win rate 40% or more
- Salted Caramel49.0%
- Coffee47.5%
- Neapolitan47.3%
- Mango44.6%
- Dulce de Leche44.5%
- Cheesecake41.8%
- Cotton Candy41.4%
- Pistachio40.4%
Dtier, win rate 25% or more
- Butter Pecan38.1%
- Coconut36.3%
- Black Cherry36.2%
- Peppermint34.3%
- Matcha Green Tea28.6%
Ftier, win rate 0% or more
- Rum Raisin18.1%
Standings
Every entrant with its record. Ordered by win rate, steadied for small samples; a rate shows once an entrant has 30 matchups. n is the number of head-to-head matchups behind each rate.
| # | Choice | W–L | Win rate | Against .500 | Titles | n |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cookies & CreamOreo pieces | 308–107 | 74.2% | 37 | 415 | |
| 2 | Cookie DoughRaw dough chunks | 301–116 | 72.2% | 25 | 417 | |
| 3 | Mint Chocolate ChipGreen & refreshing | 208–138 | 60.1% | 14 | 346 | |
| 4 | VanillaTimeless favorite | 238–160 | 59.8% | 12 | 398 | |
| 5 | ChocolateThe classic | 212–152 | 58.2% | 6 | 364 | |
| 6 | 185–134 | 58.0% | 8 | 319 | ||
| 7 | Peanut Butter CupReese's-inspired | 184–146 | 55.8% | 12 | 330 | |
| 8 | Birthday CakeSprinkles & vanilla | 162–152 | 51.6% | 6 | 314 | |
| 9 | StrawberryFruity classic | 147–144 | 50.5% | 6 | 291 | |
| 10 | Rocky RoadChocolate, nuts & marshmallows | 152–149 | 50.5% | 5 | 301 | |
| 11 | Salted CaramelSweet & salty | 143–149 | 49.0% | 7 | 292 | |
| 12 | CoffeeCaffeinated treat | 124–137 | 47.5% | 8 | 261 | |
| 13 | NeapolitanThree-in-one | 132–147 | 47.3% | 4 | 279 | |
| 14 | MangoTropical delight | 111–138 | 44.6% | 4 | 249 | |
| 15 | 118–147 | 44.5% | 3 | 265 | ||
| 16 | 107–149 | 41.8% | 2 | 256 | ||
| 17 | Cotton CandySweet & colorful | 94–133 | 41.4% | 3 | 227 | |
| 18 | PistachioGreen & nutty | 108–159 | 40.4% | 6 | 267 | |
| 19 | Butter PecanButtery & nutty | 90–146 | 38.1% | 2 | 236 | |
| 20 | CoconutTropical cream | 90–158 | 36.3% | 3 | 248 | |
| 21 | Black CherryRich cherry flavor | 93–164 | 36.2% | 3 | 257 | |
| 22 | 82–157 | 34.3% | 0 | 239 | ||
| 23 | Matcha Green TeaJapanese-inspired | 63–157 | 28.6% | 4 | 220 | |
| 24 | Rum RaisinBoozy & fruity | 32–145 | 18.1% | 0 | 177 |
Closest rivalries
Pairs the crowd can barely split, from at least 20 real meetings each.
- VanillavsPeppermint12–8 in 20 meetings
Most lopsided
- VanillavsPeppermint12–8 in 20 meetings
Upsets and oddities
Patterns in 180 finished brackets.
- UntouchableCookies & Cream wins 74.2%The best record in the field (n = 415 matchups).
- ClutchMatcha Green Tea: 4 titlesOnly #23 on win rate, but #16 for championships.
- Always the bridesmaidChocolate: 58.2% win rate#5 on record, but only 6 titles in 180 brackets.
- Still waitingPeppermint: no titles yetWins 34.3% of its matchups (n = 239) and has never been crowned.
Questions people ask
What is #1 in the Ice Cream Flavors community ranking?
Cookies & Cream. It wins 74.2% of its head-to-head matchups (n = 415) and took the title in 37 of 180 finished brackets.
How is the ranking worked out?
Every pick in a finished bracket is a win for one entrant and a loss for the other. Entrants are ordered by win rate, steadied toward 50% by ten imaginary matchups so that a newcomer with a 3–0 record can't top the table. The rate shown is the real one, with n, the number of matchups behind it.
Why win rate and not titles?
Draws are shuffled, so a title can come from an easy path. Win rate counts every matchup an entrant played, which is a fairer read of how people feel about it. Title odds are shown too, as the share of finished brackets each entrant won.
How many people have ranked Ice Cream Flavors?
180 finished brackets so far, with 3,484 head-to-head picks between them. Only finished brackets count.
Can I rank all 24 myself?
Yes. Play the bracket at 8, 16, 24 entrants, free and with no sign-up. You get your own ranking and a link to share, and your picks join this page.
How often does this page update?
About every hour, as new brackets are finished.
More brackets
Your turn: is the crowd right?
Pick a winner in every matchup and see where you agree with 180 players, and where you don't.