Ice Cream Flavors Community Rankings
The cumulative ranking of all 24 entrants, built from 43 completed Ice Cream Flavors brackets and 909 head-to-head picks. Cookies & Cream currently leads on win rate.
Last updated September 30, 2026
Play the Ice Cream Flavors bracket43
brackets completed
909
picks recorded
24
entrants with results
Full community ranking
- 1
Cookies & Cream
88W - 24L · won 12 brackets
79%
win rate
- 2
Cookie Dough
90W - 36L · won 6 brackets
71%
win rate
- 3
Vanilla
65W - 37L · won 3 brackets
64%
win rate
- 4
Chocolate
51W - 36L · won 1 bracket
59%
win rate
- 5
Mint Chocolate Chip
52W - 37L · won 3 brackets
58%
win rate
- 6
Strawberry
49W - 37L · won 3 brackets
57%
win rate
- 7
Peanut Butter Cup
44W - 41L · won 2 brackets
52%
win rate
- 8
Brownie Batter
41W - 39L · won 1 bracket
51%
win rate
- 9
Rocky Road
39W - 38L · won 1 bracket
51%
win rate
- 10
Salted Caramel
37W - 38L · won 2 brackets
49%
win rate
- 11
Neapolitan
36W - 38L · won 2 brackets
49%
win rate
- 12
Birthday Cake
36W - 38L · won 1 bracket
49%
win rate
- 13
Cheesecake
34W - 37L · won 1 bracket
48%
win rate
- 14
Dulce de Leche
30W - 38L
44%
win rate
- 15
Cotton Candy
31W - 40L · won 2 brackets
44%
win rate
- 16
Pistachio
31W - 40L · won 1 bracket
44%
win rate
- 17
Mango
30W - 39L
43%
win rate
- 18
Black Cherry
26W - 40L · won 1 bracket
39%
win rate
- 19
Coffee
24W - 40L · won 1 bracket
38%
win rate
- 20
Butter Pecan
20W - 38L
34%
win rate
- 21
Peppermint
15W - 40L
27%
win rate
- 22
Matcha Green Tea
14W - 38L
27%
win rate
- 23
Coconut
14W - 41L
25%
win rate
- 24
Rum Raisin
12W - 39L
24%
win rate
How this ranking works
How is the Ice Cream Flavors community ranking calculated?
Every completed Ice Cream Flavors bracket adds one result to the pool. Each head-to-head pick is recorded as a win for one entrant and a loss for the other, and entrants are ordered by win rate across all 909 matchups played so far. Champion counts are tracked separately so a lucky draw cannot pass as a favourite.
Why use win rate instead of how often something wins the bracket?
Brackets are shuffled, so an entrant can reach the final without beating anything difficult. Win rate counts every matchup an entrant appeared in, which is a fairer read on how people actually feel about it. Champion counts are shown next to it for the entrants that keep taking the title.
How often does this ranking update?
Continuously. The page rebuilds every few minutes, so a bracket you finish now shows up here shortly afterwards. Last refreshed September 30, 2026.
Does my own ranking have to match this one?
No — this is the aggregate, not a verdict. Play the ice cream flavor tier list yourself and you get a private result page with your own order, which you can share and compare against the community list here.